📚 CBSE Grade-10 Study Guide
HomeEnglish — Language and Literature (184)

English — Language and Literature (184) — CBSE Class 10 board question

Q1. [6]
How does the method of the seagull's mother to teach her child to be independent contrast with Amanda's mother's constant nagging ? Examine how this affects the emotional responses of the seagull and Amanda. ('Two Stories about Flying' and 'Amanda!')
Previously asked in CBSE board exam
2026 2/3/1 Q10(a)
Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 · 2026-06-15 07:19 · grounding rag
Model Answer

Method of Teaching — Contrast:

The seagull's mother uses a strategic, loving method to make her young one fly. She withholds food, ignores his cries, and then tempts him with fish just out of reach — forcing him to dive instinctively. Her tough love is purposeful: she knows he can fly and engineers the moment.

Amanda's mother, in contrast, constantly nags her — stop slouching, don't eat chocolate, don't bite nails, don't hunch. She imposes rules without understanding Amanda's emotional need for freedom and imagination.

Effect on Emotional Responses:

The seagull's fear transforms into exhilaration and triumph. Once he dives, terror gives way to joy — he soars, joins his family, and "completely forgot that he had not always been able to fly." The experience builds confidence.

Amanda, however, retreats into fantasy — she imagines herself a mermaid, an orphan roaming freely, Rapunzel in a tower. The constant nagging makes her sulky and withdrawn, escaping mentally because she cannot escape physically.

Conclusion: The seagull's mother trusts nature and guides through action; Amanda's mother controls through words — one builds independence, the other stifles it.

Source: Chapter 3 — His First Flight; Amanda! (First Flight, Class X)

---

Explanation
If a question refers to an image, map, graph or diagram that is not shown here, find the actual CBSE question paper on the CBSE website: cbse.gov.in.
Previous-year CBSE Grade 10 board exam questions, organised by subject and chapter, each with a model answer — free to read and print.