Q1. [2] § 5.1 WHAT ARE LIFE PROCESSES? § 5.2.1 Autotrophic Nutrition
"Transpiration in plants is a necessary evil."
Comment on the statement giving two reasons.
Previously asked in CBSE board exam
2026 31/4/1 Q10
Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 · 2026-06-07 16:37 · grounding rag
Model Answer
Transpiration is called a "necessary evil" because:
- Evil (harmful): Plants lose large amounts of water through stomata during transpiration, which can cause wilting and water stress, especially in dry conditions.
- Necessary (useful): It creates a suction pull that helps in the upward transport of water and minerals from roots to leaves through xylem. It also helps in cooling the plant.
Explanation
The phrase "necessary evil" means something harmful but unavoidable because it also brings benefits. Examiners expect one reason why it is harmful and one reason why it is beneficial. The key benefit is the transpiration pull driving water transport through xylem. Note: this topic is from Chapter 6 (Life Processes — Transport in Plants), which is in your syllabus even though the provided passages don't explicitly cover transpiration; these are standard NCERT-expected points.
If a question refers to an image, map, graph or diagram that is not shown here, find the actual CBSE question paper on the CBSE website:
cbse.gov.in.