The Silesian weavers' revolt of 1845 was directed specifically against their contractors rather than against the government or the aristocracy. What does this suggest about the nature of the economic exploitation they faced?
Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 · 2026-06-26 13:38 · grounding rag
Model Answer
The Silesian weavers' revolt of 1845 was directed against their contractors because it was these middlemen who directly exploited them economically. The contractors supplied raw materials and placed orders for finished textiles, but drastically reduced the weavers' payments, taking advantage of the desperate need for jobs among workers. The weavers' enemy was not the government but the capitalist-contractor system — a form of exploitation rooted in the early industrial economy where middlemen controlled both the supply of materials and the prices paid for labour, leaving home-based weavers with no bargaining power.
Source: Chapter 1, Section 3.2 – Hunger, Hardship and Popular Revolt
---
Explanation
- The question asks you to analyse what the revolt's target reveals — so go beyond just describing the revolt; explain why the contractors were the immediate oppressors.
- Key examiner expectation: link the desperate need for jobs (mentioned by journalist Wilhelm Wolff) to the contractors' power to reduce wages — that's the economic exploitation angle.
- Avoid vague phrases like "they were poor." Be specific: contractors controlled raw material supply AND payment rates, making them the direct agents of exploitation.
- 3 marks = one clear point + explanation + conclusion. This answer does exactly that in ~90 words.