📚 CBSE Grade-10 Study Guide Open in the Study Guide single page app →
HomeEnglish Language & Literature

English Language & Literature — CBSE Class 10 board question

Q1. [3]
What excuses did Mrs. Pumphrey make about Mr. Herriot's advice ?
Previously asked in CBSE board exam
2023 2/6/1 Q9 (b)
Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 · 2026-06-15 07:10 · grounding rag
Model Answer

Mrs. Pumphrey made several excuses to avoid following Mr. Herriot's advice. When asked about cutting down sweet things, she said Tricki seemed so weak that she had to relent, as he loved cream cakes and chocolates. She also claimed Tricki suffered from malnutrition, so she gave him extras like malt, cod-liver oil, and Horlicks. Regarding exercise, she excused herself by saying the gardener, Hodgkin, was down with lumbago, so ring-throwing had stopped.

Source: A Triumph of Surgery, Tricki's Condition and Hospitalisation

---

Explanation

Examiners expect three distinct excuses — one for sweet things, one for extra feeding (malnutrition claim), and one for lack of exercise (gardener's lumbago). Each excuse should be stated clearly and briefly. Quoting specific details (cream cakes, Horlicks, lumbago) shows close reading and earns full marks. Avoid padding with your own opinion.

If a question refers to an image, map, graph or diagram that is not shown here, open the Study Guide single page app, go to Library and find the actual CBSE question paper. The original papers are also available on the CBSE website: cbse.gov.in.
Previous-year CBSE Grade 10 board exam questions, organised by subject and chapter, each with a model answer — free to read and print.